Beiträge von Leon
-
-
Well, in my world at least, it's never really helpful for a vanilla townie to claim freemason since it provokes the real freemason to counterclaim just causing conflict. Hence if a person that has claimed freemason dies as a townie I would just suppose they actually were the freemason.
And if they die as a wolf... well even more obvious.
That's the assumption I'm going off of. And with that in mind I really don’t see a scenario.
I know... strategies where a townie falsely claims freemason and the real freemason goes along with it and doesn't counterclaim etc. etc. .... in reality I just don't think thats helpful.. even less since we can't tell after the false freemason has died. So that's nothing I would ever recommend doing.
-
As far as I'm concerned, if only one player claims to be the freemason he is pretty much confirmed good. If two players claim freemason we know (exactly) one of them is evil. That's quite a lot of info. Now what is the downside to doing this?
I'm not telling the wolves how they can use this
and sure, it is unlikely they already died but it is a possibility and we can't confirm the role through the one claiming it dying.So what?? Like literally why does it matter if we can confirm the role through the one claiming it dying? Give me a single scenario where that's important.
You think Xsi youkd be a wolf but you rather lynch me? Why?
Wut?
How would that help?
Not gonna explain it again
-
-
And if you think outing the old man is not a good Idea at least out the freemason...
How do you think this will help? Because as far as I'm concerned the freemason will still die as vanilla townie. That is, if they are still alive.
Why does that matter how the freemason will die?

As far as I'm concerned, if only one player claims to be the freemason he is pretty much confirmed good. If two players claim freemason we know (exactly) one of them is evil. That's quite a lot of info. Now what is the downside to doing this?
And as far as the freemason being dead goes: well we only had 2 vanilla townie die so far. Jadio said, that he was a vanilla one, so no freemason there. Then just a slight chance Daro was one, but that's rather unlikely.
VOTE: Leon since there are not enough non-vanilla townies left for a role call to solve anything, any outing will just help the wolves right now imo.
Well it doesn't have to solve the entire game for it to be helpful....
Sure one could argue, that we should wait another day with the role call, but that's kinda risky since we might already lose the game today if Xsi is a wolf. The other risk in waiting is, that it makes it more likely, that the freemason already died when doing the role call, making for an easy bluff. And not doing a role call at all is just an utter waste of the role.
That being said, after all it's probably the best option to just lynch someone and if they are a non-vanilla role they still have the option to out themselves in order to not get lynched. Just scared this results in chaos.
-
-
-
-
-
Alles anzeigen
What you mean by someone claiming their actual role.
What the word deciced is supposed to mean. If it's supposed to be "decided", what do you mean by decided that way? What have I (or you) decided? What does that have to do with needing facts to explain a feeling?
Why do you even need facts to explain a feeling in the first place? Who do you mean by players who only rely on logic, because I don't?
And overall: next time I'm telling you that someone else is claiming their actual role? In what world would I tell you, that someone else is claiming their actual role and what dies that have to do with anything? I don't get it.
Jadio claimed to be vanilla (= claimed his actual role and not a fake one) & got lynched afterwards
My gut aka tummy said, that he's telling the truth (so it decided that I should believe his claim)
You wanted a reason why I trusted his claim even though I told you before that it was a gut feeling...so yeah, the person I was talking about was you
Bit clearer now?
So was it because of his role call itself or was it a general feeling?
-
What you mean by someone claiming their actual role.
What the word deciced is supposed to mean. If it's supposed to be "decided", what do you mean by decided that way? What have I (or you) decided? What does that have to do with needing facts to explain a feeling?
Why do you even need facts to explain a feeling in the first place? Who do you mean by players who only rely on logic, because I don't?
And overall: next time I'm telling you that someone else is claiming their actual role? In what world would I tell you, that someone else is claiming their actual role and what dies that have to do with anything? I don't get it.
-
-
-
-
-
I even pinged you, but good to know how closely you read the game
But still I think it's kind of funny that you attack me by saying I didn't read the game closely, when literally a couple of messages above I already said, that I haven't yet read the last few pages... proving that you yourself didn't read the game closely LOL
-
-
-
-