Beiträge von Koala

Zitat von Ashley

Don't know but if I'm werewolf and another wolf makes rubbish, I like to use sarcasm to critize him on a natural way. And there are also some other player I saw it so far. At the other side from Turnov to Rheingold, I think it would fit as a team.

I also realised that now. When I wrote my post yesterday and reflected my thoughts about the four possible lynches that had some votes, I was also thinking that I have some points for Turnov and I really wish I would have relied on them. I mean there nearly couln't have been a worser candidate for the lynch then Rusty.
But Ruhrgold did not criticise Turnov weird thoughts he just laught about them. For some reason I felt unsure there yesterday and I am still not sure which of my first impressions I should follow. I will let you know when I come to a conclusion.

I am really really motivated today to find another werewolve! So I will try to put as much time in the game as possible and I am planning to set a vote at the latest in the afternoon since I am a bit busy tonight but I should be able to be at least online in case I am needed. But I don't think that ninja votes are good at that point of the game so I will avoid them as much as possible.

For a start, I have been thinking a lot about Joule and I will think more about her today since she seems really hard to categorise. I haven't reread her completely yet, but so far I haven't found a definite villager sign and probably there is none. But I started to go through Ruhrgold again. Ruhrgolds first evaluation that he did was about Joule... which made me really sceptical. All in all he only left an opinion on Joule, Greaseball (but unsure), Electra, said something to Dinah and asked her about me, and he didn't liked Ashleys first vote. If Joule is a villager he only had positive feelings about three villager and a negative one about Ashley who also voted him... It is possible for a wolve to only say something and interact with five villager ( including dinah as a third party). The way I would assume Ruhrgold plays, I don't really think that the first thing he does is saying on saturday morning his co wolve Joule seems to be a villager. But this is the only thing I can actually get out of Ruhrgold and that he criticised Ashleys first vote on Rusty. If I remember correctly, Ruhrgold was not the first player criticising Ashleys start so he was kind of swimming with the crowd here or am I wrong? Ashley just started in a unusual way, I would say it gives Ashley a villager point that he criticised one of her first actions. On the other hand protecting Ashley would not have fitted to the unsure way he presented himself. But he could have just said nothing aswell and thats what is probably more likely in case Ashley would be co-wolf. Not sure about that though.
-> Ruhrgold seems to set Ashley and Joule in a rather villager light would be my conclusions at the moment. But I might not weight that too much since I am quite unsure on that so far. At least it gives a first direction.
More will follow later.

Why can't Joule be a wolve?

Zitat von Electra

Thats quite wolf-like imo.

I wont doubt Pearl the next ~2 days either way.

well Buffy already doubted today in some of her posts, not really surprising. At least coco can't be as mad at me since she also voted then for Rusty, She probably should not as I should have voted someone else. I truly understand all the negative comments that might come now.

Really sorry Rusty although it does not make it better at all. Seems like the worst person I could have choosen.

I will go in my corner and cry, see you maybe tomorrow... I really should follow my feelings after rereading someone

Thanks for unmaking the tie Coco!
I really hope I did not messed everything up

I am sooo sorry. I have really no clue who to vote. I was even thinking of buffy again but I don't like the people voting her.

I think I will go for VOTE:Rusty
Allthough I think I am really wrong with that. I really should vote earlier to not be the one who has to decide

-----------

Verbleibende Zeit: 00:02:21

Zitat von Buffy

And so Volta is the only person left to vote

Don't think so

What is going on here? I am so confused!!!

Zitat von Coco

I would love to see Pearl's vote since it is more important than usual when few people vote.

Me too

Alright, looking at the lynch list so far:

Well I read Rusty and I found him kind of honest and not really werewolve like. I saw quite some opinion in his posts today, not the last ones, they really confused me and I felt like I could only understand half of them and also don't get why he postet that instead of normal sentences?

I was reading through Turnov earlier today, there were some things I did not understand, like for example how he can find Joule searcing, reflekting but then still her post leave a bad feeling? For me that is quite contrasting, either someone really looks searching and therefore villager-like or not. Another think I did not understand was how he can have me quite positive, at least thats something he said, giving me small village points to than lateron put me in different werewolve teams? I also had the feeling that in case he is wolve, Coco might be one too since I did not liked the way he evaluated her. Left me a slightly bad feeling.
But I found him not really teamy with Ruhrgold since Ruhrgold reacted to his assumption that the mans in this game are the werewolves with a comment and some smileys. But I guess thats only a small reason. But still why should he say he believes in male werewolves when he is one and at least his character male aswell?

Does not really fit for me. Although this is kind of my most suspicious person

Reading through volta also didn't gave me a strong feeling for either wolve or villager. The passage pover Coco and me criticising Greaseball was really weird, but why should a wolve reflect the person he just ate? Also this I hope coco would be smarter as a villager than that was really weird? Furthermore the other thinking about the night kill was suspicious but not really suitable as a werewolves unless it was his goal to leave this impression.

Buffy as menntionned before seems to be a rather relaxed villager who just writes whatever comes to her mind. Not really an option for me today

Ok that helped me absolutely nothing. I will look at the standing now and then rethink again.

Sry for being late and indecesive

Zitat von Rusty

So many ppl are talkin bout Turnov being a possible wolf , but no one is really voting them?

Did you draw a conclusion from that observation?

Zitat von Coco

I'm a little bit struggling with Pearl's assumptions about regular wolf and villager play. Why should a wolf (Rusty, to be more specific) be more actively involved in the game? And why should a villager have better thoughts?

Well depending on the conditions but in some games I found it easier to get into when I was a werewolve than as a villager. But it really depends on the content and anonymous games are anyway special and more difficult.
Well villagers can have unique thoughts or feeling and are usually not swimming with all the others. Even if the conclusions are teh same, that someone is a villager, usually the reasons for that are a bit different. But I guess its hard to say and probably not even possible to really devide here between rather wolve-like or villager-like behaviour in a usual game since this is special.

Zitat von Buffy

Vote earlier, dunno. But it's an action that could've come from a HD-Wolf as well

You're right. For today I won't be able to do it better and I hope you don't see me negative because of that. I will try to be earlier tomorrow.

Zitat von Wrench

this post just proved for me that Joule is a villager. I rly liked his thoughts there

+1

Zitat von Joule

Anyway, sorry if you took it personally. I'm very happy about your decision

No worries, I am not that affected by things like that. I am happy too and I will as promised give my best today aswell.

No Panic, your leader is almost there!!

I have to say I like it that there are more votes there today, I am just not sure whether I like the distribution of them, but I will try to vote as quickly as possible. I am sadly still busy with thinking, reading and drawing conclusions.

Zitat von Flat Top

I don't understand how you got to that no-team conclusion.

Can you explain that a little bit more?

Ruhrgold-buffy I would say its more likely that Buffy for some reason just liked him or his introduction as a villager than really as a wolve. Since as a wolve most people are more careful and usually only put a cowolve saver if there are reasons for that. Buffy seemed at that point not really like a person that actually thought very long about that opinion and how she could justify her thoughts. Which makes it for me a bit more likely hat buffy is not a teammate to Ruhrgold. I see her anyway not too bad so far I think. She reminds me of some players that usually just write whatever they are thinking no matter whether it could be suspicious or not.

Zitat von Flat Top

What do you think was better today?

I have nothing there in mind that showed up specific villagery.

about Ashley, I don't know, yesterday evening I was unsure and rather wanted to vote with my villagers Joule and Electra but I felt more comfortable with Ruhrgold as a lynch. I think Ashley showed on both days that she is thinking a lot, drawing conclusions and trying to show what she means, generates activity and reactions. I would consider her to be a villager. I think also her reaction after the lynch seemed authentic, unless I am not messing her up with someone else? Nevertheless, I think all in all she is different but quite good so far. Might be different when I read her again but I guess this is not the right time for rethinking everyone.

Zitat von Flat Top

As is said i tried my best!

I think you are doing well. I liked you in the beginning ( cannot remember why, but there must have been a reason) and some of your posts show that you are thinking and trying to be present in the game. For now you are totally fine

Zitat von Ashley

Hm okay, I'm surprised about that. It felt so far that you trust me and votet because of this on Ruhrgold.

No, I am mostly not really looking on who voted who, but since there were only so few voted yesterday I was quite unsure. And you were not really my favourite villager at least not a person I would trust instantly. I am really more having my own mind

Zitat von Ashley

Can me say somebody some striking point about Dinah. She's a little bit out of my focus today.

Iirc Dinah had a quite authentic reaction to the lynch yesterday and some good thoughs throughout the game aswell. Maybe not as much as others but all in all with her start, the way she defended herself in the beginning and so on, I had the impression that she is a good person

Zitat von Ashley

Furtermore I like Flat tops actual activity, Wrench posts today I liked.

Do you only liked flat tops activity or also the content or the style of his posts?


So villagers for today: Joule, Electra, wrench, Dinah, Ashley,

there were some things I liked in buffys Posts and I would see her rather villager like than wolves.

Coco is active, villager-like but I am not really sure so far whether I am right there.

Hello everyone! I am still at work, well doing home office, so somehow working, but I should have enough time tonight!

Zitat von Buffy

Ok, so in my opinion that speaks against a Rusty and Joule team, but I am pretty sure, that at least one of them is a wolf.

Joules seems to my quite wolfish (you know, the other translations for that word are quite funny xD)

I can't really follow your thoughts. Rusty might be a wolve (although I am asking myself why he wouldn't be able to participate more as a wolf in the game instead of not being able to get into it better... I mean being a wolf is hard but you have teammates that can help ya and there should be always something to say even with less time. ). What I don't understand is how you think that Joule could be a wolve? Her posts seem quite logical to me and maybe the one before the lynch can be faked but the rest? I am thinking a lot about her and Electra since I am unsure whether both of them might be good in manipulating others and doing unpredictable things, but for me yesterday evening and their posts speaks for them being a villager. Probably I am now a more favourite of Electra than joule ( yesterday was the other way around), but I do think that Joule is positive.
So I would be really interested in hearing what you don't like about her posts since she had quite many with lots of content in them.

Zitat von Electra

Wrench: ++ (Especially her last posts seems villager-like to me. For example the reaction to buffy feels like a typical villager uncetainty (and is authentic to me))

I agree on that, seems authentic to me aswell

Zitat von Electra

Joule: +/- (at the moment, I again dont know how I feel about her. It's a bit like a rollercoaster ride, as I get villager and also a few (but rather less) wolf vibes from her )

Same as buffy: Where did you get the wolf vibes? (All I feel is villager vibes and paranoia)

Zitat von Wrench

still no fan of rusty, just rly seems to be either not in game or dont wanting to be in game

I had the same impression although as menntionned above, I really don't understand why he shouldn't get in the game as a wolve... On the other hand villager usually have more individual thoughts and feelings unless they really just focos on the active players... I am really unsure when it come to Rusty since he is defending himself kind of wolves like, not bringing much new thoughts and all in all a bit unmotivated and desperate?

Zitat von Flat Top

what do you say about buffys - ruhrgold tendency?

Rather no team than a team but I would actually not validate that too much

Zitat von Electra

Thats great! I would have wondered otherwise.

Made my day You are quite funny

Zitat von Buffy

Tbh, I think I'm going to reread the lynch, because I've got an Aluhat to that

Aluhat, funny aswell. I don't think I share your conclusions, although you are right that It does not draw a good light on myself to vote so late. I am not gonna apologize for that, since it was also a bit my plan to get reactions to that. And I have to say, the outcome was better than I thought (of the lynch, the reactions were quite predictable)

But whoever said that my vote was pure luck, thats not nice at all! Especially since half of the people that person listet, I would not have votet. Nevertheless, I wasn't sure with Ruhrgold, but I can ensure you that I was thinking about everything quite long so that my vote was not out of the blue. But I did not liked ashleys vote there to be honest. Today she is doing better than yesterday but I am still a bit unsure.

Zitat von Buffy

Well, gg to Ruhrgold, I still like his entry-posts xD

??

Zitat von Electra

I like that post from Flat Top. Seems totally authentic and motivated

I disagree. For me it was a bit too much of the drama and not so much real thoughts? I am sorry if I criticise your personality with that Flat top, I can ensure you that I don't want that but it did not look super authentic to me. Nevertheless, the posts afterwards looked better and indeed you seem to be motivated and maybe I just need to go through your posts again to actually judge the content of it. So please do not feel offended!

Zitat von Buffy

Flat-Tops hm. I'm not sure. I mean on the one hand it's nice, that she have noticed. my strange villager-opinion concerning Ruhrgold, on the other hand wolves of cause, are also searching for possible-teammates to their dead fellow-wolf. And what really hits me of is the fact, that flat top didn't vote me? think that's more wolfish than something else. But daaamn, I really have no clue bout that, let's say Flat Top is under investigation xD

I like that you are not sure about him and see him critical, but I don't like that the only thing you are reffering to is the part about yourself. Leaves me a slightly bad impression on you.


See you later guys!

Zitat von Dinah

Why should Electra vote Ruhrgold like that, if they're wolves together. The only way I could a imagine a scenario like that would be if Caboose's also a wolf and I think it would be a strange coincidence if all of the three who got the most votes are wolves..

Yeah true

Zitat von Electra

I already have been on Caboose, but later on switched to Ruhrgold after you have voted him.

I know, it was a tie and I might have switched if you wouldn't have. But then probably on caboose since I thought you might be a villager which seems now even more likely

I think the reaction of Joule before we knew that he was a wolf, made her a villager. I think she should be quite safe now, unless she is really good in faking that and call a lynch neutral where a wolf comes out in the end.

Zelda I am not so sure, Electra can be a teammate but still he was the one confirming the lynch and he could have also voted caboose easily. But without the vote, maybe I would have voted someone else to undo the due. Not an easy situation for Electra, but all in all I think he's good

I like Dinah so far so that I would agree with her being a villager.
But to be honest: I think you were really quick with reading through Ruhrgold and writing your thoughts... maybe too quick? I am a bit doubting at the moment, you seem to be a villager, but are you really one?

I probably have more luck than I should.

I know what you mean Joule but I don't know who else to vote since I like Electra and I think Caboose might be more villager than Ruhrgold. Perhaps all of them are villager or electra is a wolf, I don't know.

I am really unsure what to do, but I think I will go for VOTE:Ruhrgold

-----------

Verbleibende Zeit: 00:06:18

Zitat von Joule

I hope that I can read everything before the deadline and then make a good decision.

It's actually funny that you say you want to read through everything to make a decision but you already set a vote in the same post?

Besides that, I really like you. You seem really active to me, searching for suspicious people and all in a quite good way.

Zitat von Electra

I miss the searching part a bit

Me too, Ruhrgold seemed more villager-like yesterday, today there were not really good posts right?

I had the impression that ruhrgold is getting more active now and more in the game but I can't really see much outcome so far. But I am also not convinced yet of him being a werewolf although I don't really have a better idea.

Zitat von Electra

Volta is not in a team with Coco I think.

Yes it doesn't look like it.

So far I am not happy with this day since there are not many posts or real disscussions. I guess sunday is not the best day to discuss I also had less time than actually planned but family is always crossing plans

Zitat von Turnov

why is being asked questions a nightmare for you?

I think I never said that? I actually like questions, I am not sure whether I can answer them all but I will try to, so go on!

Zitat von Turnov

I hope you know, that this is a real point of responsibillity. For me a leader has to be very strong.

I will give my best, might just take another day to be strong. But concerning your werwolf male theory I guess I got lucky

By the way: I hope you get well soon! Headaches are really bad. Turnov post seems a bit fuller with evaluations and thought that it acutally is which leaves a slightly bad feeling. Any opinions on Turnov @all?

Zitat von Ruhrgold

Yes that has to be the solution to the game

Looks like it.... unfortunately my favourite suspect of the hour is a woman. Is that a sign now that buffy is innocent?

I really have to say that reading Buffys Post made my feelings go up, down, up, down, up and so on. I don't know why but first impression was wolf, then I thought her arguments are not too bad but then I had the impression that her whole Post was pre written. Which I don't really understand. I really really don't know how to evaluate Buffys Post.

Sh1n  Zelda you seem quite critical in general, what do you think of Buffys Post?

Zitat von Ashley

So this a little bit more confrontive style is a way for me to find a little bit in it, because I was sure to get reactions for my personally play and so I can better play with you. It worked.

I thought so already and I definitly see the advantages of that style even though I would never be able to play like that or then be able to get the reactions I actually wanted.

Zitat von Ashley

But maybe it's only my view, but me personally helped day 0 still not really to find something.

I agree on that. I feel like I have written so much without actually having more than some tendencies that can change quickly. Which is not good at all. It's only 5 pages, not really much for a day zero. I guess getting in the game is for most of us more difficult than usually. I would be happy if some more people participate.

And to answer your question about opinions to other players: I liked flat top in the beginning and I think I disliked turnov but I cannot really remember why. I have a long list of players that I want to reread